Mack Daddy’s New York Slice – 13 Sep 2016


Half n Half 16″ Pizza – Big Tony’s Pepperoni and Buffalo Chicken $27

Big Tony’s Pepperoni – a perfect combination of hot and smokey pepperoni with grande mozzarella

Buffalo Chicken – Louisiana base, buffalo chicken, ricotta, blue cheese and romano

Mack Daddy's New York Slice - Big Tony Pepperoni and Buffalo Chicken1

New York Style Cheesecake $10

Mack Daddy's New York Slice - New York Style Cheesecake

Rick and creamy with a buttery crumb. Served with raspberry coulis


Mack Daddy’s New York Slice Food Review Summary

Verdict: Great to see an American style pizza joint open up on the popular Beaufort Street strip of eateries. They serve a range of 16″ and 22″ pizzas and also offer the option of half n half which I gladly took up. I placed a takeaway order and picked up a 16″ Big Tony’s Pepperoni pizza on one half and Buffalo Chicken on the other half. I also got a serve of the New York style cheesecake. The pizza is large and a few legs bolted on to the huge pizza box, and I’d have a mini table! Granted it was takeaway and not eaten at it’s optimum, I thought the pepperoni pizza fell a bit short. The pizza has a lovely thin base that holds it’s shape (it’s not floppy) and has a crunchy crust. The pepperoni is tasty with a lovely sprinkling of herbs to add additional flavour, though I found it a bit flat. If cheese is overcooked it becomes chewy and not the kind of chewy with stringy gooey mozzarella. On the other hand, the buffalo chicken is moist and intense. The blue cheese is the first flavour to smack you in the face, though the spiciness comes through as well. The different combination of cheeses create a moistness and soft cheesiness and makes it a really enjoyable pizza. Unfortunately the cheesecake didn’t have it’s seatbelt on and hit the floor, hence the crack in the cheesecake. Pouring the raspberry coulis all over and launching into it, I was pleasantly surprised. The baked New York style cheesecake is a classic and this was so delicious. I loved the creamy but not too rich flavour of the cheesecake and that raspberry coulis helps to balance out the richness. I like the biscuit crumb base. Yum! Very happy. A good pizza offering but needs a little more of a pep in flavour.
Price: Reasonable
Taste: Delicious
Value: Reasonable
Recommendation: Recommend

Mack Daddy’s New York Slice Restaurant Details

Mack Daddy’s New York Slice on Facebook
Mack Daddy's New York Slice Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato

Like This Food Blog & Want A Second Helping?

Feel free to subscribe via RSSRSS or be RSS Via Emailupdated via email each time a new post comes out on Alternatively, bookmark this foodie site on your favourite social media site below. Remember, when it comes to food, it’s all about the taste.


Mack Daddy's New York Slice - 13 Sep 2016, reviewed by Shaun on 2016-09-13T18:33:27+00:00 rating 3.7 out of 5